Home › Blog › Why Are People in your state Paying $1,200+ a Month for Health Insurance?

Why Are People in your state Paying $1,200+ a Month for Health Insurance?

By Martin Elefant · Licensed insurance agent · Updated October 2026 · 5 min read

Every January we hear the same thing from 1099 contractors: "My premium is $1,200 and I never go to the doctor." Here's why that happens.

Reason 1: you're above the subsidy line

Marketplace plans are built around the premium tax credit. If you earn too much to get it, you're paying the sticker price designed to be subsidized. Nobody tells you that's what happened.

Reason 2: guaranteed issue has a cost

HealthCare.gov plans must accept everyone regardless of health, and can only price on age, location and tobacco. A healthy 45-year-old and a 45-year-old with multiple chronic conditions pay the same. The healthy person is subsidizing the pool.

Reason 3: your state's market

Rules, carriers and prices vary by state — pick your state on our quoter to see exactly what's available where you live. A few states (New Jersey, California, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, DC) have their own individual mandate; most don't.

The option most people were never shown

Private shared-network plans — PPOs on the Cigna, Aetna and PHCS PPO networks — price on your health instead of your income. For a healthy person they are often $400–$700 a month less than full-price marketplace coverage, with a national network. They aren't for everyone: there's a health questionnaire, and serious pre-existing conditions can be declined. But if you're healthy and over the subsidy cliff, you're exactly who they were built for.

If you're paying $1,200 a month, you deserve to see the alternative. Check your options — it takes 60 seconds.

ME
Martin Elefant
Licensed insurance agent · NPN 20765405 · Lyons Life LLC · 1099 Private Health

See your real options

Both markets, one call. Or call (561) 363-7776.

Check My Options →
Check My Options →